Buying a used car can be exciting but stressful. Facebook Marketplace has made it simple to scroll through endless listings, but simple doesn’t always mean safe. The truth is, while private sellers might dangle lower upfront prices, the risks can easily outweigh the savings.
Licenced dealers, on the other hand, operate under strict rules and consumer protections, which give you a safety net that Facebook sellers simply can’t match. If you’re serious about getting a reliable used car and avoiding nasty surprises, a licenced car dealer is almost always the safer option.
1. Vehicle History and Legal Protection
When you buy privately, you’re mostly relying on trust. A car could be hiding an accident history, still have finance owing, or in the worst cases, even be stolen. If that happens, you’re left with the mess.
Licenced dealers are legally required to sell cars with a clear title and honest history. Many also put their vehicles through mechanical checks and inspections before selling. That layer of accountability makes a huge difference compared to taking someone’s word for it on Facebook.
2. Proper Warranties, Not Just Promises
Private sellers almost always sell cars “as-is.” If something breaks down a week after purchase, you’re on your own.
With licenced dealers, warranties are often part of the package. For example, My Car Choice offers cover for up to 36 months, giving you real protection against costly repairs after you drive away. This kind of support is something you’ll never get when buying from a private seller online. This applies to all, whether you get a Honda or a Land Rover.
3. Roadside Assistance for Extra Peace of Mind
Breakdowns happen, but it’s how you deal with them that matters. If you’ve bought a car off Facebook and it breaks down on the way home, chances are the seller won’t answer your calls.
Licenced dealers sometimes include extras like 12 months of roadside assistance with their vehicles. That means if you’re stuck with a flat tyre, dead battery, or mechanical failure, you’ve got someone to call. It’s a small detail, but one that can make a huge difference.
4. Cars Are Properly Serviced Before Sale
Marketplace cars often come as-is—maybe cleaned, rarely serviced. Unless you’re a mechanic, you can’t be sure of what’s really under the bonnet. Some brands, like Toyota, have an excellent reputation, but you still need to get it checked.
Licenced dealers usually service their vehicles before listing them for sale. That means the basics like brakes, tyres, and fluids are taken care of. It saves you from driving straight to a workshop right after spending thousands on a car.
5. Registration and Compliance Are Sorted
Registration can be another hassle when buying privately. Sometimes you need to transfer it yourself; other times, the car comes unregistered, leaving you to sort the paperwork and pay the fees.
With licenced dealers, registration is normally handled before the car leaves the lot. We even provide 6 months NSW registration included in the sale. It’s one less thing to worry about and helps you get on the road quicker.
6. Quality Standards, Not Guesswork
On Facebook Marketplace, a seller might say “runs well” or “great condition,” but words are cheap. Photos can be misleading, and sometimes problems only show up once you’ve already handed over your money.
Licenced dealers, however, have reputations to protect. Cars usually go through multi-point inspections and quality checks before they’re sold, which means you’re buying something with verified condition, not guesswork.
7. More Secure Transactions
Dealing with private sellers often means cash handovers in car parks or people’s driveways. Unfortunately, scams are common, and once the money’s gone, there’s little you can do.
Dealers operate through proper channels with legal paperwork and secure payment methods. You’re not just handing money to a stranger; you’re buying through a business that has to follow regulations.
While we are on the price, also check our blog on the top used car brands with the highest resale value.
8. Know Your Rights
One of the biggest differences between buying from a licenced dealer and Facebook Marketplace is the legal protection you get.
There are guarantees under the Motor Dealers and Repairers Act 2013 (MDRA) and the Australian Consumer Law (ACL) that apply when buying and selling used vehicles through licenced dealers.
Dealer guarantees under the Motor Dealers and Repairers Act 2013 include:
- A guarantee that the vehicle is free from encumbrances and that the buyer receives full title.
- A dealer guarantee covering certain defects that may appear after purchase.
These protections don’t apply when you’re buying privately. On Facebook Marketplace, once you’ve handed over the money, you’re left without legal safety nets.
Final Verdict: Buying a Car from the Facebook Marketplace or a Dealer
Facebook Marketplace might seem tempting with cheaper-looking cars, but there’s no warranty, no guarantees, no checks, and no aftercare. It’s a gamble that can cost you more in the long run.
Licenced dealers, on the other hand, offer proper protections under law, plus extras like warranties, roadside assistance, registration, and quality checks. You’re not just buying a car, you’re buying peace of mind.
If you want that added security, it’s clear that going through a licenced dealer is the smarter move. At My Car Choice, every car is inspected, serviced, and comes with quality assurance, roadside assistance, and warranty options. It’s everything Facebook Marketplace can’t provide, making it not just the safer choice, but the better one for your wallet and peace of mind. Find Used Cars in Sydney and book your car stress-free. We have even used car loan options.
